Comments on: So that History won’t be “history” http://jakartabutuhrevolusibudaya.com/2008/10/09/history-wont-be-history/ Bukan Sekedar Advokasi, Kami Berkontribusi Mon, 19 Apr 2010 09:37:41 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: nien http://jakartabutuhrevolusibudaya.com/2008/10/09/history-wont-be-history/#comment-2313 nien Thu, 16 Oct 2008 04:36:29 +0000 http://revolusibudaya.wordpress.com/?p=439#comment-2313 <i>...Clearly, it would be nice if the objectives of the history class go beyond memorizing dates, names and information. Teachers should aim for bigger goals such as cultivating students interest in the world or pride in their own country...</i> Yes... I do agree with you I love history but i hate history subject, feels better to find it by myself, reading books, or searching the internet cara pengajaran butuh revolusi juga? :) …Clearly, it would be nice if the objectives of the history class go beyond memorizing dates, names and information. Teachers should aim for bigger goals such as cultivating students interest in the world or pride in their own country…

Yes… I do agree with you
I love history but i hate history subject,
feels better to find it by myself, reading books, or searching the internet

cara pengajaran butuh revolusi juga? :)

]]>
By: yonna http://jakartabutuhrevolusibudaya.com/2008/10/09/history-wont-be-history/#comment-2312 yonna Thu, 16 Oct 2008 04:19:48 +0000 http://revolusibudaya.wordpress.com/?p=439#comment-2312 halo Stephanie welcome to the club :) I used to trust History lesson. Jaman sekolah dulu ada mata pelajaran Sejarah dan PSPB. Tapi setelah dewasa apalagi saat kuliah, saya mulai tidak mempercayai keakurasian dan kebenaran naskah Sejarah. Is it history or his story? Sejarah ditulis berdasarkan penulisnya (subyektif) dan tidak melulu berdasarkan fakta sejarah itu sendiri. Just like my lecturer said "Jangankan sejarah yang usianya ratusan tahun, berita yang terjadi tiga hari lalu saja sudah simpang siur kebenarannya" Even she doubts it :) Paragraf ini: Secondly, even with a History major, one can find jobs in other fields. Business, finance, and government are such fields that employ those with a History degree. I agree, untuk yang satu itu termasuk dalam ilmu pengetahuan umum yang harus kita ketahui dan diingat. common knowledge tepatnya. Tapi tidak semua perusahaan menanyakan pertanyaan sejarah saat wawancara, apalagi sejak jaman reformasi ini, mgkn hanya Departemen dan BUMN yang masih memberlakukan pertanyaan tersebut saat wawancara. Untuk perusahaan swasta tepatnya tidak semuanya menanyakan hal2 berbau sejarah. I'm glad knowing that you are studying history. I think it's a big opportunity for you to unveil the truth beneath the history. I'm sure there are some truth being hidden to protect certain people's interest. The truth is unveiled for example is about Muhammad Natsir and PRRI, there are so much error during Soeharto regime, but right now everyone knows who Pak Natsir was and what PRRI was. We can read about it on book 100 Tahun Muhammad Natsir. PRRI was never a rebellion once, PRRI loved Indonesia, I agree from the first place, even when I still heard the contrary version. Thank God, right now we know what PRRI was for. "History, let it be pure history, don't change it to His Story" halo Stephanie welcome to the club :)

I used to trust History lesson. Jaman sekolah dulu ada mata pelajaran Sejarah dan PSPB. Tapi setelah dewasa apalagi saat kuliah, saya mulai tidak mempercayai keakurasian dan kebenaran naskah Sejarah. Is it history or his story? Sejarah ditulis berdasarkan penulisnya (subyektif) dan tidak melulu berdasarkan fakta sejarah itu sendiri. Just like my lecturer said “Jangankan sejarah yang usianya ratusan tahun, berita yang terjadi tiga hari lalu saja sudah simpang siur kebenarannya” Even she doubts it :)

Paragraf ini:
Secondly, even with a History major, one can find jobs in other fields. Business, finance, and government are such fields that employ those with a History degree.

I agree, untuk yang satu itu termasuk dalam ilmu pengetahuan umum yang harus kita ketahui dan diingat. common knowledge tepatnya. Tapi tidak semua perusahaan menanyakan pertanyaan sejarah saat wawancara, apalagi sejak jaman reformasi ini, mgkn hanya Departemen dan BUMN yang masih memberlakukan pertanyaan tersebut saat wawancara. Untuk perusahaan swasta tepatnya tidak semuanya menanyakan hal2 berbau sejarah.

I’m glad knowing that you are studying history. I think it’s a big opportunity for you to unveil the truth beneath the history. I’m sure there are some truth being hidden to protect certain people’s interest. The truth is unveiled for example is about Muhammad Natsir and PRRI, there are so much error during Soeharto regime, but right now everyone knows who Pak Natsir was and what PRRI was. We can read about it on book 100 Tahun Muhammad Natsir. PRRI was never a rebellion once, PRRI loved Indonesia, I agree from the first place, even when I still heard the contrary version. Thank God, right now we know what PRRI was for.

“History, let it be pure history, don’t change it to His Story”

]]>
By: Bunga http://jakartabutuhrevolusibudaya.com/2008/10/09/history-wont-be-history/#comment-2310 Bunga Mon, 13 Oct 2008 16:41:15 +0000 http://revolusibudaya.wordpress.com/?p=439#comment-2310 This is a very good article! Indonesians should realize that history is a very important "ilmu" not only math and science. This is a very good article! Indonesians should realize that history is a very important “ilmu” not only math and science.

]]>
By: Izmi http://jakartabutuhrevolusibudaya.com/2008/10/09/history-wont-be-history/#comment-2304 Izmi Fri, 10 Oct 2008 07:08:15 +0000 http://revolusibudaya.wordpress.com/?p=439#comment-2304 I think so. :) I think so. :)

]]>